Should We Believe Assurances That ICE Won’t Arrest Undocumented Immigrants Fleeing Hurricane Harvey?

Commentators have been understandably worried for non-citizens battling flooding and other problems caused by Hurricane Harvey, which hit the coast of Texas on August 25, 2017.

Not only is their basic safety at risk, but there’s the matter of the new immigration enforcement priorities under the Trump administration.

This really means no priorities at all, but an environment in which anyone who encounters Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) or Customs and Border Protection (CBP), regardless of their close ties to the U.S. and past agreements that they were law-abiding and not a priority for deportation (including with DACA grants), are fair game for deportation.

Non-citizens have been arrested while at their most vulnerable: for example, when appearing in court to testify to domestic violence, when leaving hypothermia shelters, and when attending check-in interviews at ICE offices.

But now, in response to these concerns, FEMA has issued a statement assuring the public that, “Routine non-criminal immigration enforcement operations will not be conducted at evacuation sites, or assistance centers such as shelters or food banks.”

That’s welcome news, at least compared with other possible things the statement could have said. But it’s also not entirely reassuring, because it leaves open the door to “criminal” enforcement operations.

As anyone who’s following the new enforcement environment knows, Trump had originally assured the public that ICE priorities would focus on criminals or “bad hombres,” then proceeded to¬†define anyone who had crossed the U.S. border illegally as a criminal.

In this situation, the climate of fear that’s been created could end up costing human lives. And it also makes it far to easy for scammers to prey on the immigrant community; including the recently reported fake ICE agents that have been banging on doors and ordering people to evacuate (presumably in order to steal their stuff).