Lyralisa Sevens is a California transgender prison inmate. Stevens was born a male but identifies as female. California provides Stevens with hormone replacement therapy, but Stevens is housed with male prisoners because Stevens’ male genitalia is intact. Stevens has sued the state, asking a court to order the state to pay for a sex-change surgery that will result in Stevens’ transfer to a female prison.
Stevens claims that a male prison is a dangerous place for an inmate with feminine deportment and breasts. That’s probably true. But judges cannot justify ordering a cash-strapped state to pay many thousands of dollars for a convicted murder’s non-emergency surgery.
The state should take reasonable steps to keep Stevens safe from other prisoners. But at a time when California has had to cut back severely on support for education and social services, an order that Stevens (and undoubtedly hundreds of other prison inmates) is entitled to a sex-change operation would be unconscionable.