Tag Archives: debt collection

Can the IRS and Student Loan Creditors Collect From Me When I’m on SSI?

Erasing DebtASK LEON 

Bankruptcy expert Leon Bayer answers real-life questions.

Dear Leon,

I am writing for a friend who doesn’t speak English.  He is worried about creditors levying his bank account to collect two old debts (a student loan and a tax debt). Should he file for bankruptcy? 

Juan is 61 years old and recently started receiving Supplemental Security Income (SSI). He will qualify for Social Security benefits soon. The student loan debt is very old (30 years) and is now $18,000 but was originally around $8,000. He hasn’t paid the loan for a long time and the creditor told him they “can take his Social Security or his SSI.” 

The second debt is old federal income taxes, around $10,000. He has failed to file tax returns for many years (perhaps as many as ten), but he has had little or no income during the same period. He wants to know if the IRS can take some or all of his SSI or later his Social Security for unpaid taxes. 

Thanks in advance for your expertise,  

Manny

Dear Manny,

Based on what you’ve told me, Juan can most likely get rid of his student loan debt because he is totally and permanently disabled. And it is almost certain that he doesn’t have enough income for the IRS to take anything from him for the old tax debt. Bankruptcy won’t be necessary.

Discharging Student Loans Based on Total and Permanent Disability

There are basically two types of student loans – subsidized (often called federal student loans) and unsubsidized (called private student loans). Subsidized loans are made or guaranteed by governmental entities. They subsidize the interest rate so that the loan interest will be less than what private lenders normally charge. Unsubsidized student loans are made by private banks. They usually charge an interest rate that is higher than subsidized loans, but still less than ordinary consumer loans.

I am sure that Juan has a subsidized loan. When he got his student loan 30 years ago, private unsubsidized loans were basically unheard of.

The distinction is important for Juan. Lenders of subsidized loans are subject to federal regulations that allow for the loan balance to be forgiven if the borrower is totally and permanently disabled, and without financial means to pay the loan. Because Juan is 61 years old and receiving SSI, he must have already convinced the Social Security Administration that he has a total, permanent disability, and lack of any other income.

How to Cancel a Student Loan Due to Disability

If Juan’s loan is indeed subsidized, he can apply online here:  www.disabilitydischarge.com.  You can submit your SSI award letter to prove you are disabled if the award says your review is not sooner than five years. Otherwise, you will need to get a letter from your doctor. (To learn more about canceling student loans because of disability, see Nolo’s article Canceling Student Loans: Permanent Disability or Death.)

Getting Rid of Unsubsidized Student Loans

If Juan has an unsubsidized loan, he is out of luck. Private lenders normally will not forgive a loan. However, in this situation he might be able to discharge the loan in bankruptcy. While wiping out a student loan in bankruptcy is difficult, lately more and more courts are discharging loans like Juan’s – very old loans where the debtor is elderly and disabled and has no hope of earning income in the future. Unfortunately, Juan would likely need an attorney to help him do this, and it sounds like he doesn’t have the money to pay what could become very high legal fees to fight with the student loan collectors.

IRS Collection Standards: When the IRS Cannot Take Your Income 

Now let’s deal with Uncle Sam, the good old IRS. According to the website of the IRS Taxpayer Advocate, the IRS can take a person’s Social Security benefits in order to repay tax debts. However, as the advocate’s website also states, the IRS must allow the tax payer to retain enough money to cover modest basic necessities. These living expense allowances are called Collection Financial Standards.

I am certain that Juan’s SSI benefit does not leave him enough to pay for basic necessities pursuant to the Collection Financial Standards. His income won’t even come close to exceeding the amount of money he is legally allowed to keep.

Juan should immediately contact the IRS and ask them to mark his account as “current uncollectable status.” They will verify his income, match it up to the living expense allowances in their collection standards, and see that his income is below the level they are allowed to collect from. It is a process that can be done on the telephone, and they will do the form for him.

Let’s recap. Juan should request forgiveness of his student loan on the grounds of total, permanent disability. He should also contact the IRS and request “current uncollectable status.”

Juan won’t need to file for bankruptcy.

— Leon

Leon Bayer is a Los Angeles bankruptcy attorney.  He is a partner at Bayer, Wishman & Leotta, a California law firm specializing in bankruptcy.  The opinions and advice in this blog post are from Mr. Bayer alone, and should not be attributed to Nolo.  By answering a question on this blog, Mr. Bayer does not become your lawyer.

Find Leon on Google+

Debt Collection Scam in Texas?

Consumer Complaint iStock_000004051547XSmallASK LEON 

Bankruptcy expert Leon Bayer answers real-life questions.

Hi Leon,

On Friday I received a call from a debt collector in Texas who said he was going to file an affidavit against me based on a loan I took out in 2006 and didn’t pay back. He told me to call a different phone number to make the payment. I called that number and the person who answered said I better pay up or they would get a warrant for my arrest. He said the account originated in California, where I used to live, but was transferred to the criminal office in Texas. I have not lived in California for at least six years. 

I don’t believe I owe the debt and asked for documents to validate the claim. 

Does this sound like a scam? If so, should I contact the local police department? Should I consider bankruptcy? 

Thank you, 

Patricia 

Dear Patricia, 

I think you handled this very well. I have lots of good stuff to tell you. 

Requesting Verification of a Debt 

The Federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) gives you the right to contest the validity of a debt and to demand documents to verify the amount, validity, and the collector’s legal right to collect the debt. (Learn more about the FDCPA, including what it requires and prohibits.) 

As of now, you don’t know if the person who contacted you is authorized to collect this debt or even if you ever owed it. You were wise to demand verification. However, in order to trigger the collector’s duty to provide you with documents backing up its claim, you need to put the verification request in writing. 

The collector is supposed to advise you of your right to demand verification of the debt within five days of its first communication with you. You have 30 days from that notice to send a written verification request. Once it receives your request, the collector is supposed to stop collection efforts until it responds. 

Of course I realize the debt collector won’t give you its address – so you can’t send the written demand. I believe the reason he won’t give you an address is to prevent you from giving the written notice demanding debt verification. 

I doubt this will ever wind up in court. But if it did, there is at least one California case saying that your verbal demand for debt verification is good enough. I am certain that no court would ever reward the deceitful, illegal behavior of this despicable debt collector by faulting you over the failure to give a written demand. Especially where, as here, the debt collector has deliberately concealed its location. 

The FDCPA Prohibits False Threats 

The FDCPA also prohibits debt collectors from lying to you and making false threats. Debt collectors do not have the power to get you arrested, so threatening to do so is a violation of the FDCPA.    

The Statute of Limitations Defense  

Assuming this is a debt that was made while you were living in California, you may have other legal protections as well. The debt could be subject to California’s statute of limitations. Under that law, a lender usually has only four years in which to file a lawsuit against you (usually the four years starts when you first defaulted on the debt). It sounds like a lawsuit to collect this debt may already be time barred. 

What to Do? 

I bet the debt collector already knows all of this. The collector wanted to scare you into paying before you could find out your legal rights. I have some advice: If the collector calls you again, tell him that you are recording the call. I’m certain you will either scare him off, or else force him to be civil and respond with legitimate information to validate the debt. 

If the collector ever does provide you with documentation, your next step would be to meet with a lawyer. A lawyer can advise you if the debt is still valid, and whether or not you should consider filing bankruptcy.  

In the meantime, you can also file a complaint about the debt collector with Consumer Financial Protection Bureau at www.consumerfinance.gov/complaint.

Sincerely,

– Leon

Leon Bayer is a Los Angeles bankruptcy attorney.  He is a partner at Bayer, Wishman & Leotta, a California law firm specializing in bankruptcy.  The opinions and advice in this blog post are from Mr. Bayer alone, and should not be attributed to Nolo.  By answering a question on this blog, Mr. Bayer does not become your lawyer.

Find Leon on Google+